In the immortal words of Forrest Gump: “Life is like a box of chocolates. You never know what you’re gonna’ get.” But in the case of Too Faced’s Box of Pink Chocolates ($27.50; toofaced.com), life is so much better because you can actually decide what you’re getting. The oversize palette contains 20 pink and brown glosses that are perfect for mixing and matching, along with a handy lip brush. You might blend the Sheer Raspberry Rose with the Vibrant Coral. Or you could amp up the Golden Rose Shimmer with a high-sheen topcoat of Sheer Raspberry. Or, for a plumper-looking pout, you could apply a layer of Deep Shimmering Plum, then blend a hint of Champagne Shimmer toward the center of lips. Unlike some palettes, Box of Pink Chocolates offers enough dreamy shades and finishes that you can truly choose for yourself. In addition to its myriad options, much like its namesake, this palette really does smell like chocolates—making it a purchase that’s just too tempting to pass up. —Ava Williams